Councillors deferred a decision on 38 homes in Gargrave today after voicing concerns about pedestrians walking on the busy Marton Road.
The application was submitted by R N Wooler and Co Ltd and follows a previous bid for housing on the site that was refused by the former Craven District Council in January 2023.
The homes will all be built with sandstone with the majority having either two or three bedrooms.
The site would be accessed directly off Marton Road via a new junction.
No footpaths to Gargrave were proposed as part of the application, which has been a common bone of contention among the 223 objectors.
They say it will be dangerous for residents wanting to walk to and from the village.
However, the council’s highways department issued no objections to the scheme following an assessment.
Gregory Butt from Gargrave Parish Council addressed the Skipton and Ripon planning committee this afternoon to say hundreds of people had objected to both applications with road safety the “paramount concern”.
He added: “We are astounded these issues remain unaddressed.”
A dairy farm near the site recently intensified its operations which has resulted in a large increase in agricultural traffic.
Conservative councillor Simon Myers, who represents the area, spoke to say there are now farming vehicles going up and down Marton Road every hour during the summer, which is a potential hazard for pedestrians. He said more homes will exacerbate the problem.
Despite Cllr Myers being in charge of housing on the council’s executive, he urged the planning committee to refuse the plans. He said: “Gargrave is not full of NIMBYs. It needs more housing and affordable housing but we must not compound problems for residents.”
Planning agent Jamie Pert spoke on behalf of the applicant and said concerns about the impact on roads had been addressed. He said: “In the interest of robustness we provided technical information in response to comments. Impact on traffic has been assessed by your experts and is considered minimal.”
Councillors visited the site in the morning and several noted the number of large farming vehicles that came past.
Cllr Nathan Hull, who represents Washburn and Birstwith for the Conservatives, said as a father of five children he was concerned about the impact of traffic. He said: “My heart is telling me it’s not a good site to develop. I’d be frankly scared that one of my children would get squashed.”
Councillors unanimously voted to defer the plans and asked the highways department to assess the impact of traffic on Marton Road. They also asked if any traffic calming measures such as speedbumps could be included as part of the application.
The application will come again before a future planning committee.
Accessibility boost as new changing places toilet opens in Malham
Tourist tax would be 'total game changer', says Mayor
Skipton Charity golf day to be held for 2025 Pride of Britain winner
North Yorkshire taxi drivers call for fare increase to offset Iran War fuel increases
Devolution will fail if decisions are York-centric, say angry North Yorkshire councillors
Craven Lawn Tennis Club to open grounds for fundraising weekend
Tory councillor used photo of tragedy which claimed the lives of 116 children to make point on social media
Airedale Hospital's cancer team launch radiotherapy website
Skipton MP raises concerns over changes to 580 bus service
Lothersdale and Glusburn students to climb Yorkshire Three Peaks for Airedale Hospital
Police investigate assault in Skipton
Glusburn Community & Arts Centre calls for funds to keep the lights on
Northern passengers reminded some train times will change from Sunday
Jumble sale to be held in aid of woman's cancer journey
Thornton Hall Country Park Continues to Grow with New Team Members
Skipton Boxing Club nominated for 'Local Hero' award
Skipton Beer Festival shares 2026 lineup
Clubberthon raises over £7,000 for hospice charity
Your Skipton collaborates with Skipton BID for first visual podcast
Skipton BID to host first ever launch event for Skipton Business Awards 2026
