A hugely controversial decision to refuse planning permission for a farm shop in Silsden has been upheld by a Government Inspector.
Plans by Isherwood’s butchers to build a new farm shop and café next to the golf driving range on Keighley Road in the town had attracted a huge amount of local support, with over 900 people writing letters of support for the planning application.
But in April, Bradford Council’s Keighley and Shipley Planning Panel refused the plans.
Planning officers had argued that the site lay in the Green Belt, and national planning policies said such developments would be inappropriate.
The panel agreed, and voted to refuse the farm shop.
In the wake of the refusal Keighley MP Robbie Moore called the panel’s decision “hypocritical and non sensical.”
Isherwoods then lodged an appeal against the refusal – meaning it would be a Government appointed inspector, and not Bradford Council, that would have final say on whether the farm shop could be built.
The business argued they needed to expand, and there was no other location in Silsden town centre that could meet its needs. The farm shop would represent a huge investment, and create local jobs.
The appeal claimed that planning officers had presented “very biased information” to the panel, and urged a planning inspector to visit the site.
It said the plans had huge support, “including from our local MP (then) Defra Agriculture Minister Robbie Moore.”
Planning Inspector T Burnham was appointed to decide on the appeal, and visited the site on 28th August.
In the appeal decision that has just been published, they concluded that the planning panel had made the right decision, and argued there was “no special circumstances” to throw out national Green Belt policies in this case.
Explaining the decision, the inspector said: “The (planning) framework establishes that the construction of new buildings within the green belt should be regarded as inappropriate unless they are a type of building identified under a list of exceptions.
“The proposal does not form an exception. nor does it constitute development considered not inappropriate in the green belt. The proposal would therefore be inappropriate development in the green belt.
“A fundamental aim of green belt policy is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open. The essential characteristics of green belts are their openness and their permanence.
“The proposed building would be prominent within views from the adjacent road which is set slightly above the level of the site. Depending on the direction of travel and position on the road of the user, the building would restrict views along the Aire Valley.
“Consequently, there would be a harmful loss of openness of the green belt. The proposal would undermine one of the purposes of the green belt at this location to check the unrestricted sprawl of large built-up areas.
“The largely undeveloped nature of the site which allows extensive views through the site along the Aire Valley contributes positively to the character and appearance of the area.
“It is likely that the proposal, which would see an apparently popular business move from the centre of Silsden, would serve to erode the retail function of the local centre of Silsden and would not be in line with the desire to minimise the need to travel.”
Concluding, the decision report says: “The proposal would be inappropriate development within the green belt and would be harmful to green belt openness and would conflict with one of the purposes of including land within the green belt.
“There would be harm to the character and appearance of the area. The site would not be suitable for a farm shop and café in relation to its location having regard to development plan policy and other considerations.
“The very special circumstances necessary to justify the development do not exist.”
Robbie Moore MP told us: “This is completely bonkers and stinks of hypocrisy. It is beyond belief that the Isherwood’s application for a local farm shop has been dismissed by planners on the basis it would be harmful to the green belt. And yet, at the very same time, Labour-run Bradford Council are happy to inundate Silsden with new housing developments, and our new Labour Prime Minister wants to rip up the greenbelt for housing.
“It seems that if it is a housing application, then it is ok, but if it is a local family business wanting to grown and expand, create jobs, boost the local economy, and provide a service for Silsden which is backed by huge local support, then Labour’s attitude is completely dismissive.
“Did the planning inspector actually open their eyes when they came for a visit? This whole situation is ludicrous and lacks common-sense. I feel deeply for the Isherwood family, and indeed Silsden’s residents who have yet again been subjected to Labour’s clear double standards.
“We are now in a situation where Silsden will get even more housing but little infrastructure to service them. Labour need to realise that it is the consent of local people which should come first, not the wishes of housing developers.”
Accessibility boost as new changing places toilet opens in Malham
Tourist tax would be 'total game changer', says Mayor
Skipton Charity golf day to be held for 2025 Pride of Britain winner
North Yorkshire taxi drivers call for fare increase to offset Iran War fuel increases
Devolution will fail if decisions are York-centric, say angry North Yorkshire councillors
Craven Lawn Tennis Club to open grounds for fundraising weekend
Tory councillor used photo of tragedy which claimed the lives of 116 children to make point on social media
Airedale Hospital's cancer team launch radiotherapy website
Skipton MP raises concerns over changes to 580 bus service
Lothersdale and Glusburn students to climb Yorkshire Three Peaks for Airedale Hospital
Police investigate assault in Skipton
Glusburn Community & Arts Centre calls for funds to keep the lights on
Northern passengers reminded some train times will change from Sunday
Jumble sale to be held in aid of woman's cancer journey
Thornton Hall Country Park Continues to Grow with New Team Members
Skipton Boxing Club nominated for 'Local Hero' award
Skipton Beer Festival shares 2026 lineup
Clubberthon raises over £7,000 for hospice charity
Your Skipton collaborates with Skipton BID for first visual podcast
Skipton BID to host first ever launch event for Skipton Business Awards 2026
